Last updated:

The short answer

Repair when one part failed on a system that kept the house comfortable, the indoor and outdoor units still match, and the repair sits within our typical repair range. Price a replacement beside the repair when the compressor or indoor coil failed on an aging system, when the house was never comfortable, or when matched parts are no longer available.

Key takeaways

  • Decide after a diagnosis, never from a symptom; several faults look alike from the hallway.
  • Small electrical and drain faults on a sound system are repairs.
  • A failed compressor or coil is the moment to price a replacement beside the repair.
  • The refrigerant the system uses can settle the question on its own.
  • A replacement keeps any duct problem the house had unless the scope includes it.

The system stopped, someone found the cause, and now there are two prices on the table. The right choice depends less on the age of the unit than on what failed, how the house felt before, and whether the parts still match.

Sweet Olive repairs and replaces ducted heat pumps across New Orleans, and we price both options when a major part fails. This guide sets out what to compare after the diagnosis. If you haven’t had one yet, start with heat pump repair or the warning signs guide.

Start with what actually failed

Each fault points a different way. This table covers the common ones and the decision each one usually leads to.

What failed What it means for the system Usual next step
Run capacitor or contactor A small electrical part; the compressor and coils are untouched Repair
Blocked condensate drain or tripped float switch The system shut itself off to protect the ceiling Clear and repair the drain; check why it blocked
Thermostat or control wiring The equipment may be sound; the call for cooling or heat isn’t reaching it Repair or replace the control
Outdoor fan motor or blower motor A moving part wore out; the refrigerant circuit is intact Repair, priced as its own line
Defrost control or sensor Heating suffers in cold weather; cooling may be fine Repair
Refrigerant leak at a valve or fitting A reachable leak that can be repaired and tested Repair, then pressure test and recharge
Leaking indoor or outdoor coil A major component; the leak may return elsewhere on an older coil Price a replacement beside the repair
Reversing valve Stuck in one mode; replacing it means opening the refrigerant circuit Price both on an aging system
Compressor The most expensive part of the system Price a replacement beside the repair

Common heat pump faults found on diagnosis, what each means for the system, and the usual next step.

Symptoms aren't a diagnosis

Warm air from the vents can be a failed capacitor, a frozen coil, a low charge, a blocked filter or a thermostat set to the wrong mode. Several of those are small repairs. Ask for the cause and how it was confirmed before you weigh replacement; our components guide shows where each part sits and what it does.

New upright air handler in the same Woodmere hall closet, the gas line capped
An air handler in its closet: the drain, the coil and the blower sit behind these panels.

The questions that change the answer

Two systems with the same failed part can deserve different decisions. These are the inputs we weigh.

  • How the house felt before the failure. A system that kept every room comfortable is worth repairing; one that always left a damp hall or a hot back bedroom carries that problem into any repair.
  • The condition of everything else. A corroded outdoor coil, a rusted drain pan or a worn blower changes what a single repair buys you.
  • The repair history. A second refrigerant leak on the same coil, or repeated drain failures, says more than the current fault.
  • Whether parts still match. The indoor and outdoor units are rated as a pair; a replacement part has to keep that pair working.
  • The ducts. Leaks or high static pressure can make a healthy system look undersized.
New six-inch flex run strapped clear of stored boxes in a Bayou St. John attic
Flex runs in an attic; a duct fault can look like an equipment failure from inside the house.
New matched heat pump outdoor unit on the same pad beside a Metairie ranch house
The outdoor unit's nameplate shows the refrigerant it was built for.

When the refrigerant decides it

Older systems charged with R-22 depend on a refrigerant EPA lists among the phased-out HCFCs, with servicing of existing equipment among the remaining uses. Newer systems moved on as well: under EPA’s technology transitions rule, residential split systems installed from January 1, 2025 use refrigerants with a global warming potential of 700 or less, unless every specified component was made or imported before that date. A new outdoor unit often can’t be paired with an old indoor coil, so a compressor or coil failure becomes a question about both halves.

What each option costs

Both prices come from the diagnosis and the visit. Here are our typical ranges and what sits outside them.

Sweet Olive's typical range for a residential heat pump repair is $161 to $661. The diagnostic visit is its own line, and a major component such as a compressor or an indoor coil is priced separately once we know what failed.

Sweet Olive's typical range for a residential ducted heat pump replacement is $4,250 to $11,750. We set your price after the site visit and write it into your estimate, with the equipment, ductwork, electrical work and permit each on their own line.

Repair

Fixes the failed part and leaves the rest as it is.

  • Lower cost now
  • The system keeps its age, its refrigerant and its sizing
  • Any comfort or duct problem stays
  • Right when the house was comfortable before

Replace

New matched equipment, sized from a load calculation.

  • Higher cost now, inside our typical replacement range
  • Resets the equipment, the refrigerant and the size
  • Ducts change only if the scope includes them
  • Right when the house was never comfortable or parts no longer match

Put the two written prices side by side with what each one changes, not just the totals.

A repair estimate and a replacement estimate are not two prices for the same thing. One restores the system you had; the other changes it. Our cost guide shows what moves a replacement price within the range, and the rebate guide covers the Energy Smart rebate on qualifying equipment installed by a participating contractor.

What a replacement fixes, and what it doesn't

New equipment solves equipment problems. It only solves house problems when the scope includes them.

Equipment problems a replacement settles

A worn compressor, a leaking coil, a refrigerant that is hard to service and controls that can’t run stages all go with the old system. The new one is sized from a room-by-room load calculation, not from the old unit’s tonnage, which can correct a size that was always wrong.

House problems it carries over

A new system set on a restricted return, a crushed flex run or a bedroom with no way back to the return carries the old complaint into the new equipment. We test the ducts before reuse, and our ductwork guide shows what those tests find. If the ducts fail, fixing them belongs in the same scope.

Day oneDay twoProtectionRecoveryRemovalPlacementConnectionsTestingSetupHandover
The working days of a replacement: protection, recovery, removal and placement, then connections, testing and handover.

Not sure yet? Get the measurements first

When the failure is minor but the system has never felt right, measure before you decide.

  • An inspection gives you airflow, static pressure, charge and drain condition on the system you have; see heat pump inspection.
  • The nameplates tell us the age, size and refrigerant of both units.
  • A year of comfort notes, such as which rooms ran warm or damp and when, shows whether the size was ever right.
  • A replacement estimate from a visit, written line by line, so you can set it against the repair; see heat pump replacement.

If the repair is small and the house was comfortable, repair it and keep the readings for next time. If the repair is large, the refrigerant is hard to service or the house never felt right, the replacement estimate is the comparison worth making.